Greeley
Greeley staff propose changing raw-water requirements for apartments, and cutting them for parks
The proposals would set different requirements by bedroom count, reduce water dedication for city parkland and revise fees and irrigation rules. Staff will bring them back for discussion and approval in coming months.
Greeley water staff proposed Nov. 18 to lower the raw-water dedication required of multifamily units to 30,000 gallons per unit for one- and two-bedroom units, down from 35,500, while raising it to 43,000 for units with three bedrooms or more.
Staff presented the multifamily changes to the Water and Sewer Board for feedback. The proposed amounts would also apply to attached single-family properties when irrigation is served through a fully separate service line. Staff said the figures rest on a study of more recently built Greeley properties and that the 35,500-gallon requirement set in 2019 is higher than most smaller multifamily properties use.
Staff also proposed removing the handful of residential taps from the raw-water surcharge list. They said data from four large multifamily properties showed the dedication was enough to prevent surcharges, and that the proposed changes would not lead to surcharges for those properties. Staff said one unit in a 24-unit apartment building could not significantly affect the building's total demand, and that removal would avoid a potential cost that could be passed through to rent. They said buildings in a multifamily development would tend to balance each other's water use.
For parks, staff proposed cutting the raw-water dedication for parkland given to the city from 3 acre-feet per acre to 2.33 acre-feet per acre, unless detailed landscape plans support a different irrigation demand. Staff said the lower amount reflects xeric and non-irrigated features, and that parks are not fully turf.
Staff also proposed requiring 2.33 acre-feet per acre of hypothetical parkland when a developer pays cash in lieu of dedicating land. Staff confirmed that this water payment would be separate from the cash-in-lieu payment for parkland.
Staff said changing development trends, construction styles and water-use patterns had exposed gaps in the city's water and sewer code and design criteria. They said high costs for water, land and labor make building in Colorado expensive while demand for housing remains. Staff will bring the proposed changes back for discussion and approval in future months.
Staff proposed removing language that could require commercial users who exceed their raw-water allotment in consecutive years to dedicate additional raw water to match their use. Staff said the existing surcharge makes the city whole, and that payments over several years are more valuable to the city than a one-time dedication.
Staff cited anecdotal concerns that a possible large dedication could make financing hard for a small business, including a laundromat whose owner and lender worried that higher business and water use could trigger a large one-time cost.
Staff proposed revising multifamily sewer plant investment fee language so comparable properties pay the same fees whether units are individually metered or on a master meter. Staff said that under current language a six-unit individually metered building would pay $9,050 per unit, while a rental six-plex on one master meter would pay $6,790 per unit.
Staff proposed raising the single-family lot-size threshold for required non-potable irrigation from 0.33 acres to 0.5 acres. Staff said the new threshold aligns with the large-lot exemption for water dedication and would reduce how often lot-to-lot non-potable irrigation is required. They said it is often hard to provide lot by lot because of added piping costs and constrained road widths and utility space.
Staff said recent lots have mostly been about 6,000 square feet, or about 0.17 acres, and few developments have lots near 0.5 acres.
Staff proposed allowing a service from the water main to serve two to six individual residential or commercial services through a manifold, rather than requiring the service line to keep the same diameter from tap to meter.
Staff said a manifold could split one 1-inch line into four 3/4-inch services, letting four users be billed individually while reducing city-responsible piping and the space used on a site. Staff also proposed clarifying that separately platted units must have separate water services, saying the current code covers separate services for individual structures but not separately platted units within a structure.
Staff said the proposed changes would add language allowing the director to take action to protect health and safety related to the water system. Staff said the Greeley Mall had illustrated a need for stronger enforcement authority, and that it was reviewing language from peer communities.
Board member Matt Anderson said he had encountered planner pushback against landscaping choices, including bluegrass, and urged staff to tell developers the utility has supply. "We're in the business of selling water, and we want to generate revenues," he said.
Staff replied that it regularly tells potential residential, commercial and industrial users the city has capacity and wants to sell water. Staff said city landscaping rules and section 6 of its design criteria limit high-water-use areas, and that the water and sewer landscaping criteria do not restrict bluegrass on single-family residential properties.
A board member asked staff to update the board on the non-potable master plan, including what it envisioned, what had happened since its adoption and how the system would be built out.
Staff agreed to provide an informational update and said planning documents set targets of around 7,000 acre-feet a year of non-potable use, with master planning guiding where infrastructure would be installed. Staff said the city has no set schedule for when areas will receive non-potable water because installation of ponds and pump stations is driven by developers.
Staff said some proposed changes, including manifold meters, had already been discussed with developers, and that the multifamily raw-water requirements drew on developer-provided data that staff checked against its own.
Staff said it would be willing to coordinate an outreach meeting with the development community. After receiving feedback, staff plans to return with draft code changes for further board feedback or approval and may take the changes to City Council for codification in late spring of next year.