The NoCo Herald

Larimer and Weld counties, Colorado

Clear, 53° in Fort Collins at 5:10 PM. Forecast high 65, low 34.

Home sales in Firestone

What homes sold for in Firestone, as the county assessors record them. A sale reaches their records two to seven weeks after it closes, so the latest weeks fill in as they post.

Homes
sold
in
Firestone

In Larimer County

In Weld County

in September 2026

2026

2025

at any price
,
newest first
.
Start over
Home sales
34
Median price
$535,000
Median a sq. ft.
$283
New construction
30%
Median gain on last sale
+16%
Median price to value
103%

The assessors are still posting September's sales, which reach their records two to seven weeks after they close, so its count will grow; it is set against other months from Nov. 19.

How these are counted

The median a square foot is over the 30 of these sales whose living area the assessors record. New construction is a home's first sale within two years of being built: 10 of the 33 whose history the records tell. The gain is on the home's last sale the records hold since it was built, over 20 resales; over the 20 held a year or more, +2% a year. Price to value is a sale's price over the county's 2026 actual value, which Colorado's assessors set in the 2025 reappraisal from the market as of June 30, 2024; over 22 sales, new construction left out.

$1,116,300, 12958 Wayfarer Circle, Firestone$692,000, 5103 Preserve Place, Firestone$756,900, 5408 Starling Way, Firestone$900,000, 5706 Wayfarer Circle, Firestone$845,000, 5534 Riverbend Ave., Firestone$800,000, 12735 Lake Port St., Firestone$981,400, 12946 Wayfarer Circle, Firestone$820,000, 5950 Twilight Ave., Firestone$645,000, 12842 Bay St., Firestone$644,300, 10536 Cimarron St., Firestone$660,000, 10080 Cedar St., Firestone$600,200, 6911 Utica Ave., Firestone$500,000, 6781 Utica Circle, Firestone$554,900, 5930 Stagecoach Ave., Firestone$585,000, 6744 Utica Ave., Firestone$512,500, 12662 Stone Creek Court, Firestone$409,900, 370 Naples St., Firestone$495,000, 11431 Cherryvale St., Firestone$520,000, 5206 Gardner Parkway, Firestone$405,000, 223 5th St., Firestone$425,000, 334 4th St., Firestone$485,000, 11316 Deerfield Drive, Firestone$515,000, 12791 Crane River Drive, Firestone$540,000, 12744 Crane River Drive, Firestone$415,000, 79 1st St., Firestone$530,000, 5417 Riverbend Ave., Firestone$560,000, 10189 Cedar St., Firestone$454,900, 13323 Merrymaker Drive, Firestone$599,000, 5388 Riverbend Ave., Firestone$446,400, 5346 Gardner Parkway, Firestone$400,600, 5350 Gardner Parkway, Firestone$485,800, 6670 Stagecoach Ave., Firestone$115,000, 4595 Tilbury Court #311, Firestone$130,000, 4795 Audrey St. #260, FirestoneRank 1Rank 2Rank 3Rank 4Rank 5Rank 6Rank 7Rank 8Rank 9Rank 10

Under $400,000 $400,000 to $600,000 $600,000 to $1 million $1 million and over the highest prices, ranked below

Map © OpenStreetMap contributors

Sales by monthHomes in Firestone
020406034AugSepOctNovDec2026FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNov
020406034SepNov2026MarMayJulSepNov
Median price by monthHomes in Firestone
$500K$525K$550K$575K$600K$535,000AugSepOctNovDec2026FebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNov
$500K$525K$550K$575K$600K$535,000SepNov2026MarMayJulSepNov

Hatched months, and the dashed end of the line, are still being posted: the assessors record a sale two to seven weeks after it closes, so their counts will grow.

The figures as a table
MonthSalesMedian price
November 20260Still being posted
October 202625$520,000Still being posted
September 202634$535,000Still being posted
August 202633$585,000
July 202627$579,900
June 202634$524,500
May 202634$572,000
April 202641$545,000
March 202645$540,000
February 202631$550,000
January 202619$530,000
December 202531$520,000
November 202522$550,000
October 202530$579,500
September 202549$575,000
August 202520$550,500

Highest pricesThe top 10

The 10 highest prices Homes sold in September 2026 in Firestone
RankPriceHomeBedsBathsSq. ft.BuiltSoldSold before
1$1,116,30012958 Wayfarer CircleTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 1,845 sq. ft. (1,667 finished), garage 702 sq. ft., 0.19-acre lot553,6752026Sept. 10New construction
2$981,40012946 Wayfarer CircleTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 2,597 sq. ft. (2,107 finished), garage 669 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot552,5972026Sept. 18New construction
3$900,0005706 Wayfarer CircleRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 2,592 sq. ft. (1,860 finished), garage 689 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot542,5922025Sept. 25New construction
4$845,0005534 Riverbend Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 1,705 sq. ft. (1,387 finished), garage 724 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot553,2512024Sept. 23$855,000 in Dec. 2024−1%
5$820,0005950 Twilight Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Mountain Shadows Sub FG#1Basement 1,487 sq. ft. (1,407 finished), garage 918 sq. ft., 0.18-acre lot643,1472023Sept. 16
6$800,00012735 Lake Port St.Ranch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 4Basement 2,533 sq. ft. (628 finished), garage 697 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot432,5332022Sept. 21$746,000 in May 2022+7%
7$756,9005408 Starling WayFirestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7A0.17-acre lot4Sept. 28New construction
8$692,0005103 Preserve PlaceRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 4Unfinished basement 2,533 sq. ft., garage 697 sq. ft., 0.18-acre lot432,5332021Sept. 30$652,000 in Nov. 2021+6%
9$660,00010080 Cedar St.Two-story house, Firestone, Neighbors Point Fg #3Basement 993 sq. ft. (88 finished), garage 638 sq. ft., 0.24-acre lot342,4052020Sept. 9$469,100 in Feb. 2021+41%
10$645,00012842 Bay St.Two-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #5Unfinished basement 1,514 sq. ft., garage 606 sq. ft., 0.14-acre lot442,6252023Sept. 14$660,000 in July 2023−2%

Every saleNewest first34

Homes sold in September 2026 in Firestone
PriceHomeBedsBathsSq. ft.BuiltSold before
Sept. 303 sales
$692,0005103 Preserve PlaceRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 4Unfinished basement 2,533 sq. ft., garage 697 sq. ft., 0.18-acre lot432,5332021$652,000 in Nov. 2021+6%
$554,9005930 Stagecoach Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Booth Farms 1st FgUnfinished basement 1,000 sq. ft., garage 800 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot432,1782001$264,000 in Nov. 2012+110%
$500,0006781 Utica CircleDuplex, Firestone, Denmore Fg No. 1Garage 445 sq. ft., 0.1-acre lot432,1762025New construction
Sept. 293 sales
$585,0006744 Utica Ave.Firestone, Denmore Fg No. 10.1-acre lot3New construction
$512,50012662 Stone Creek CourtRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #1Unfinished basement 1,847 sq. ft., garage 414 sq. ft., 0.15-acre lot321,8472017$421,900 in July 2018+21%
$409,900370 Naples St.Ranch house, Firestone, Firestone Villas SubGarage 524 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot221,2352011$400,000 in Aug. 2021+2%
Sept. 282 sales
$756,9005408 Starling WayFirestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7A0.17-acre lot4New construction
$495,00011431 Cherryvale St.Split-level house, Firestone, Mountain Shadows Fg #2 Replat #1Unfinished basement 396 sq. ft., garage 661 sq. ft., 0.19-acre lot431,7902015$427,500 in Dec. 2020+16%
Sept. 251 sale
$900,0005706 Wayfarer CircleRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 2,592 sq. ft. (1,860 finished), garage 689 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot542,5922025New construction
Sept. 241 sale
$520,0005206 Gardner ParkwayFirestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7A0.08-acre lot4New construction
Sept. 231 sale
$845,0005534 Riverbend Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 1,705 sq. ft. (1,387 finished), garage 724 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot553,2512024$855,000 in Dec. 2024−1%
Sept. 212 sales
$800,00012735 Lake Port St.Ranch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 4Basement 2,533 sq. ft. (628 finished), garage 697 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot432,5332022$746,000 in May 2022+7%
$405,000223 5th St.Bi-level house, Firestone, Globe Sub 1st FgFinished basement 736 sq. ft., garage 276 sq. ft., remodeled 2021, 0.14-acre lot527881980$460,000 in June 2022−12%
Sept. 184 sales
$981,40012946 Wayfarer CircleTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 2,597 sq. ft. (2,107 finished), garage 669 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot552,5972026New construction
$485,00011316 Deerfield DriveTwo-story house, Firestone, Oak Meadows PUD FG#1Unfinished basement 638 sq. ft., garage 448 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot331,4622002
$425,000334 4th St.Ranch house, Firestone, Globe Sub 2nd FgFinished basement 1,192 sq. ft., garage 480 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot531,1921985$340,000 in May 2020+25%
$115,0004595 Tilbury Court #311Manufactured home, FirestoneGarage 288 sq. ft.321,4042011$68,600 in March 2016+68%
Sept. 171 sale
$515,00012791 Crane River DriveRanch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #1Garage 646 sq. ft., 0.15-acre lot221,3812019$428,600 in Oct. 2019+20%
Sept. 161 sale
$820,0005950 Twilight Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Mountain Shadows Sub FG#1Basement 1,487 sq. ft. (1,407 finished), garage 918 sq. ft., 0.18-acre lot643,1472023
Sept. 153 sales
$540,00012744 Crane River DriveTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #1Basement 602 sq. ft. (593 finished), garage 816 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot342,1192018$574,000 in Jan. 2025−6%
$530,0005417 Riverbend Ave.Ranch house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #5Unfinished basement 1,376 sq. ft., garage 646 sq. ft., 0.2-acre lot321,3762022$544,100 in April 2023−3%
$415,00079 1st St.Ranch house, Firestone, Firestone Villas SubGarage 524 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot221,2352010$230,000 in July 2015+80%
Sept. 141 sale
$645,00012842 Bay St.Two-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #5Unfinished basement 1,514 sq. ft., garage 606 sq. ft., 0.14-acre lot442,6252023$660,000 in July 2023−2%
Sept. 104 sales
$1,116,30012958 Wayfarer CircleTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 6Basement 1,845 sq. ft. (1,667 finished), garage 702 sq. ft., 0.19-acre lot553,6752026New construction
$644,30010536 Cimarron St.Two-story house, Firestone, Booth Farms 2nd FgFinished basement 1,402 sq. ft., garage 420 sq. ft., 0.14-acre lot542,7852004$355,000 in June 2016+81%
$560,00010189 Cedar St.Ranch house, Firestone, Neighbors Point Fg #3Unfinished basement 1,364 sq. ft., garage 732 sq. ft., 0.17-acre lot331,7902020$479,800 in Feb. 2021+17%
$454,90013323 Merrymaker DriveTwo-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7AGarage 471 sq. ft., 0.08-acre lot231,5722026New construction
Sept. 91 sale
$660,00010080 Cedar St.Two-story house, Firestone, Neighbors Point Fg #3Basement 993 sq. ft. (88 finished), garage 638 sq. ft., 0.24-acre lot342,4052020$469,100 in Feb. 2021+41%
Sept. 41 sale
$599,0005388 Riverbend Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg #5Unfinished basement 864 sq. ft., garage 676 sq. ft., 0.16-acre lot331,7982023$586,100 in Aug. 2023+2%
Sept. 34 sales
$600,2006911 Utica Ave.House, Firestone, Denmore Fg No. 10.13-acre lot4
$485,8006670 Stagecoach Ave.Two-story house, Firestone, Ridge Crest PUD FG#2Unfinished basement 693 sq. ft., garage 420 sq. ft., 0.1-acre lot431,6312001
$446,4005346 Gardner ParkwayTownhouse, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7AGarage 462 sq. ft., 0.06-acre lot331,7662026New construction
$400,6005350 Gardner ParkwayTownhouse, Firestone, Barefoot Lakes Fg No. 7AGarage 399 sq. ft., 0.04-acre lot231,5172026New construction
Sept. 21 sale
$130,0004795 Audrey St. #260Manufactured home, Firestone, Eagle Crest PUD321,4562003$46,995 in March 2013+177%

From Weld County Assessor (read 6 a.m.) and Larimer County Assessor (read 6:01 a.m.). Prices are the recorded sale prices. Deeds of several parcels at one price, quitclaim deeds and nominal transfers are left out, as are commercial property and land. What Larimer County's sales say of the home — its type, rooms, areas, year built, lot and value, and the sales before — is from the Larimer County Assessor's public improvement, account, value and sales files; Weld County's value and sales before, from its parcel and sales records. Neither names an owner here. Price bands are set about the quartiles of the last year's sales: a fifth sold under $400,000, half for $400,000 to $600,000, a quarter for $600,000 to $1 million.