The NoCo Herald

Larimer and Weld counties, Colorado

Loveland

Loveland council names nine to its charter review committee

From the Loveland City Council meeting of

After appointment, the committee is to meet at least twice per month and elect a chair and vice-chair.

Loveland City Council appointed nine residents and two alternates to a new Ad Hoc Charter Review Committee that will review the city's charter and recommend possible revisions.

After appointment, the committee is to meet at least twice per month and elect a chair and vice-chair. It must submit a public engagement plan to the council within 60 days of its first official meeting, and it is to present a final report with specific recommendations and drafted Charter revision options. The City Attorney said the city planned to hold a committee meeting in December and would work with members to schedule it.

The council established the temporary committee to resolve ambiguous language, ensure compliance with current laws, address inconsistencies and engage the community. A council member said parts of the Charter needed changes to bring them into constitutionality and to make the document more complete. The member added that there are "some definite areas in our charter that need to be changed to bring them into constitutionality."

Council members argued over appointing Michael Scholl, a school board member. A council member raised concern about appointing an applicant who also served on a school district board that, the member said, was being investigated by the federal government. A council member said the investigation involved the school district, not Scholl personally, and was not a finding of wrongdoing, and opposed excluding someone solely because an institution with which he was affiliated was under investigation.

Another council member said an applicant's other public service was not a reason to prevent him from serving, and that Scholl had joined the school board after many of the events being investigated had occurred. "I would be very hesitant to say someone can't serve simply because there's an investigation," the first member said.

Mayor Pro Tem Andrea Samson said she had reservations about appointing an elected official to the committee, including because the applicant served on the school board and the LORA board, but also described him as highly qualified. A council member suggested that the City Attorney or City Clerk review whether the boards and commissions handbook should address elected officials serving on boards or commissions and how to handle issues involving their members.

The council appointed Michelle DiPietro and Michael Scholl as regular members. The council also appointed Catherine Ficarolla as first alternate and Megan Eleazor as second alternate.

Applicants had offered a range of proposals for the committee:

  • Michele DiPietro: a process for residents to complain about perceived Charter violations, revised ethics and conflict-of-interest provisions, and proportionate penalties for violations
  • Kathi Wright: a four-year mayoral term, like the council's, and stronger enforcement when problems occur
  • Ian McCargar: a search for Charter gaps and inconsistencies, and consultation with council-appointed attorneys about current practices; he cited 43 years as a practicing attorney and 18 years in Windsor's Town Attorney's Office, 10 as Town Attorney
  • Mark Jackson: a review of the division of responsibilities between elected leaders and city staff, executive residency and at-will employment rules, council meeting practices and public comment; he cited more than 30 years of municipal and public administration experience

Council members also weighed how to pick alternates when a candidate had said they would not serve. Councilor Caitlin Wyrick supported choosing candidates who had said yes, saying it would avoid additional staff work and that those candidates had been vetted for willingness to serve. "The people who say yes, like, want the role," Wyrick said.

A council member said asking candidates whether they would serve was meant to keep staff from contacting candidates repeatedly, and supported moving down the list. Another council member said staff should contact a candidate who had said they might consider serving, but not one who had said no.

The City Clerk said the clerk would contact the selected applicants to begin background checks and would work with the City Attorney to report any findings to the council. The City Attorney said he was not aware of anyone failing the boards and commissions background check during his tenure and described the success rate as very high. He said he did not expect the council to revisit the selections, though it could happen.

The City Attorney also said members of Windsor's charter commission were willing to talk with the committee about their experience. He said the committee would have access to CERSA and people with charter-review experience in other municipalities.

More from this meeting

  1. Loveland City Council special meeting, Nov. 19, 2026

    Loveland council names nine to its charter review committee, 9-0.